Ray arrived in Nazareth in 1964, and the team had their first winning season since 1952. Nazareth defeats Easton in 1964 & 65. Easton drops Nazareth from the schedule from 1966-70.
Tom Fehr is Ray's 1st District XI Champion in 1965. The team is Lehigh-Northampton co-champion in 1966 and 67.
The 1968 team was 13-1 and won the District XI championship. It was the first time a team outside of the East Penn Conference won. The team won the Lehigh-Northampton conference outright. Coach Nunamaker was the District XI Coach of the Year. Nazareth defeated Hellertown/Saucon Valley in a dual meet for the first time. Terry Rissmiller became Ray's first Regional Champion and he went on to take 4th in States.
The 1969 team was District XI Runner-Up and Jeff Duelley became the first two time District XI champion.